Bailiff (17:15):
All rise. Circuit Court in Fort Mary County is now in session. The Honorable Timothy T. McCourt presiding.
Judge McCourt (17:21):
Y'all can be seated. Thank you. We are here in 2025 CF4516, State of Florida versus Dwain C. Hall. Will counsel for the parties identify themselves for the record?
Amy Berndt (17:34):
Amy Berndt for the State.
Rich Buxman (17:41):
Rich Buxman for the State. I'm sorry, Judge.
Judge McCourt (17:42):
I know you're working on something on your computer. You're fine.
Junior Barrett (17:46):
Junior Barrett, I represent Mr. Hall who's in the courtroom.
Jacques Ward (17:49):
Jacques Ward also representing Mr. Hall.
Judge McCourt (17:51):
Okay. Mr. Hall is present seated at counsel's table. Mr. Hall, can I have you raise your right hand, sir? Do you swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Dwain C. Hall (17:57):
I do.
Judge McCourt (17:58):
Okay. Mr. Hall, are you wearing handcuffs?
Dwain C. Hall (17:59):
No.
Judge McCourt (18:00):
Are you wearing shackles?
Dwain C. Hall (18:01):
No.
Judge McCourt (18:02):
I'd like you to stand up, take a couple steps back to your right. All right. Mr. Hall is in custody. He does not appear to be in custody. He is wearing civilian clothing. He is wearing a light blue button up dress shirt, a pair of charcoal slacks, pair of... It's a black belt. Deputy Mitchum, can you move the... There we go. Oh, nevermind. Thank you. He's wearing a pair of gray dress shoes. Is appropriately dressed for court. He is neither handedcuffed nor shackled. All right. Be seated, Mr. Hall. Thank you.
(18:39)
All right. State, is there anything from y'all's perspective the court needs to take up before we bring in the jury? If you need a minute, that's fine.
Rich Buxman (18:48):
Yes, Your Honor.
Judge McCourt (18:48):
I can do that, but is there anything that we have to address other than-
Amy Berndt (18:51):
No, Your Honor.
Judge McCourt (18:52):
Okay.
Rich Buxman (18:52):
No, Your Honor.
Judge McCourt (19:44):
I do have just a quick word for the folks who are here in the audience observing the trial. Everybody who has been here this week has behaved in an exemplary fashion. I have no reason to believe that anybody in the audience will do anything inappropriate for the remainder of the trial.
(20:01)
With that being said, I do want to just let you all know that if folks observing a trial are going to hear things that they disagree with or that they want to have some type of visible reaction to, it's oftentimes during closing arguments. So I'm just going to ask and instruct all of you during the closing arguments, refrain from most certainly audible commentary on arguments that you may hear, as well as visible commentary. Shaking one's head back and forth, sighing loudly, doing things of that nature only serves to distract the jury from the arguments that they're hearing.
(20:38)
And it's improper and inappropriate for a member of an audience to do that. The trial takes place in this part of the courtroom. So like I said, all the reactions thus far have been appropriate. Everyone's been well behaved. I just want to make sure the jury pays close attention to the closing arguments. Nothing in the audience is distracting them. So that's it. We'll get going to closing arguments in just a moment here.
Rich Buxman (20:58):
Thank you, Your Honor.
Judge McCourt (20:59):
You're confident it's ready?
Rich Buxman (20:59):
Yes, sir.
Judge McCourt (24:29):
Okay. Very good. All right. We're ready for the jury?
Amy Berndt (24:30):
Yes, Your Honor.
Judge McCourt (24:47):
Let's go ahead, and bring them in. Should y'all encounter technical difficulties during closing argument, that won't eat into your 90 minute allotment.
Amy Berndt (24:52):
Thank you.
Judge McCourt (24:52):
And if you feel we need to bring the jury out to address any technology issue, just let me know.
Amy Berndt (24:57):
Thank you very much.
Judge McCourt (24:58):
Okay. Do you want me to tell the jury that there could be an issue or...
Amy Berndt (25:00):
Hopefully not.
Judge McCourt (27:56):
All right. Ladies and gentlemen, welcome back. Counsel, everybody can go ahead and be seated. Thank you. All right. First thing we're going to do, I'm going to ask you the same question I've asked you the last three days that we've met. We took a recess last night. I instructed all of you to not learn about the case or try to learn about the case either through talking with people or through your phones or electronic devices. I also instructed you not to talk about the case with anybody or allow anybody to talk with you about the case. Let me know by nodding your heads up and down or shaking them back and forth. Have all of you been able to follow that instruction? All the jurors have nodded their heads in the affirmative. Very well. At this point, ladies and gentlemen, we're going to begin with the final phase of the trial, which will include the reading of the jury instructions and closing arguments. So I'm going to have Deputy Cabrera hand out a copy of the jury instructions to you. Once you all have a copy, I'll explain what we're going to do here and then turn you over to the lawyers. Okay? Okay. Now, what you all have been provided is a copy of the final jury instructions. So I'm going to read these aloud to you. And when you go back and deliberate your verdict, the copy that you're going to have with you of the instructions is the copy that I actually read from up here at the bench. Okay? The copy that each of you have, it is simply a copy that I've provided to you so that you can read along with it while I read it to you out loud. Hopefully that will aid in comprehension and understanding of the instructions. But again, you will have a copy of them when you go to deliberate and it will be the copy that I have.
(29:41)
I tell that to you because some jurors are inclined to take notes during closing argument or their instructions on the law. If you do that, make sure you take it on your notepads because if you take them on your copy of the jury instructions that you've been handed to read along with, we're going to be taking those back up from you and collecting them after these have all been read, so you won't get those notes back. So again, any notes you want Please take them on your notepads. Okay?
(30:04)
With that being said, what I'm going to do is I'm going to read about half of these to you. I then break for closing argument. The lawyers will then make their closing arguments. They each have 90 minutes in which to make their argument here this morning. And after that, I'll conclude with the last bit of the final instructions and then we'll identify the ultimate jurors and then 12 of you who remain on the jury to go and deliberate your verdict. Okay? That's kind of the plan of the morning.
(30:25)
So let's begin on page 1 with 3.1, introduction to final instructions.
(30:28)
" Members of the jury, I thank you for your attention during this trial. Please pay attention to the instructions I am about to give you. Dwain C. Hall, the defendant in this case, has been accused of the crimes of first degree murder and kidnapping. I will now explain these crimes to you."
(30:43)
"Dwain C. Hall is accused of first degree murder in count one of the indictment. First degree murder includes the lesser crimes of second degree murder and manslaughter, both of which are unlawful. However, a killing that was excusable homicide or that was committed by the justifiable use of deadly force is lawful. If you find Sonia Exelby was killed by Dwain C. Hall, you will then consider the circumstances surrounding the killing in deciding if the killing was first degree murder, second degree murder, or manslaughter, or whether the killing was excusable homicide or resulted from the justifiable use of deadly force."
(31:16)
"The use of deadly force to kill a human being is justifiable homicide and therefore lawful if necessarily done while resisting an attempt to murder or commit a felony upon the defendant or to commit a felony in or upon any dwelling house in which the defendant was at the time of the killing. Deadly force means force likely to cause death or great bodily harm. Great bodily harm means harm that is more than slight, trivial, minor, or moderate harm."
(31:41)
"The killing of a human being is excusable homicide and therefore lawful under any one of the following three circumstances. One, when the killing is committed by accident and misfortune in doing any lawful act by lawful means with usual ordinary caution and without any unlawful intent. Or two, when the killing occurs by accident and misfortune in the heat of passion upon any sudden and sufficient provocation. Or three, when the killing is committed by accident and misfortune resulting from a sudden combat if a dangerous weapon is not used and the killing is not done in a cruel or unusual manner. A dangerous weapon is any object that will likely cause death or great bodily harm if used in the ordinary and usual manner contemplated by its design and construction."
(32:25)
"To prove the crime of first degree murder, the state must prove the following three elements beyond a reasonable doubt. One, Sonia Exelby is dead. Two, the death was caused by the criminal act of Dwain C. Hall. Three, there was a premeditated killing of Sonia Exelby. An act includes a series of related actions arising from and performed pursuant to a single design or purpose. Killing with premeditation is killing after consciously deciding to do so. The decision must be present in the mind at the time of the killing. The law does not fix the exact period of time that must pass between the formation of the premeditated intent to kill and the killing. The period of time must-"
Judge (33:00):
... Of the premeditated intent to kill and the killing. The period of time must be long enough to allow reflection by the defendant. The premeditated intent to kill must be formed before the killing. The question of premeditation is a question of fact to be determined by you from the evidence. It will be sufficient proof of premeditation if the circumstances of the killing and the conduct of the accused convince you beyond a reasonable doubt of the existence of premeditation at the time of the killing. Sonia Exelby's consent is not a defense to the crime of first degree murder. Consent means intelligent, knowing and voluntary consent and does not include coerced submission. Coercion means the use of exploitation, bribes, threats of force or intimidation to gain cooperation or compliance. If the evidence does not convince you that the defendant committed the main crime of which he is accused in count one of the indictment, there may be sufficient evidence that he has committed a lesser included crime.
(33:53)
In other words, if you decide the main accusation has not been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, you will need to decide if the state proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty of a lesser included crime. The lesser included crimes indicated in the definition of first degree murder or second degree murder and manslaughter. I will now define these crimes for you. To prove the crime of second degree murder, the state must prove the following three elements beyond a reasonable doubt. One, Sonia Exelby is dead. Two, the death was caused by the act of Dwain C. Hall. Three, there was an unlawful killing of Sonia Exelby by an act imminently dangerous to another and demonstrating a depraved mind. An act includes a series of related actions arising from and performed pursuant to a single design or purpose. An act is eminently dangerous to another in demonstrating a depraved mind if it is an act or series of acts that one, a person of ordinary judgment would know is reasonably certain to kill her who's serious bodily injury to another.
(34:45)
And two is done from ill will, hatred, spite, or an evil intent and indicates an indifference to human life or that denotes a wicked and corrupt disregard of the lives and safety of others. To convict of second degree murder, it is not necessary for the state to prove the defendant had an intent to cause death. Sonia Exelby's consent is not a defense to the crime of second degree murder. Consent means intelligent, knowing and voluntary consent and does not include submission by coercion. Coercion means the use of exploitation, bribes, threats of force or intimidation to gain cooperation or compliance. To prove the crime of manslaughter, the state must prove the following two elements beyond a reasonable doubt. One, Sonia Exelby is dead. Two, Dwain C. Hall, A, intentionally committed an act or acts that caused the death of Sonia Exelby, or B, intentionally procured an act that caused the death of Sonia Exelby or C, caused the death of Sonia Exelby by his culpable negligence. Every person has a duty to act reasonably toward others. If there is a violation of that duty without any conscious intent to harm, that violation is negligence.
(35:47)
The defendant cannot be guilty of manslaughter by committing a merely negligent act or if the killing was either justifiable or excusable homicide as I have previously instructed you. To convict a manslaughter, it is not necessary for the state to prove that the defendant had an intent to cause death, only an intent to commit an act that was not merely negligent, justified or excusable and which caused death. To procure means to persuade, induce, prevail upon or cause a person to do something. I will now define culpable negligence for you. As I have said, every person has a duty to act reasonably toward others. If there is a violation of that duty without any conscious intention to harm, that violation is negligence. But culpable negligence is more than a failure to use ordinary care toward others. For negligence to be culpable, it must be gross and flagrant.
(36:33)
Culpable negligence is a course of conduct showing reckless disregard of human life or a grossly careless disregard for the safety and welfare of the public. The negligent act or omission must have been committed with an utter disregard for the safety of another. Culpable negligence is consciously doing an act or following a course of conduct that the defendant knew or reasonably should have known was likely to cause death or great bodily harm. Sonia Exelby's consent is not a defense to the crime of manslaughter. Consent means intelligent, knowing and voluntary consent and does not include submission by coercion. Coercion means the use of exploitation, bribes, threats of force or intimidation to gain cooperation or compliance. Dwain C. Hall is charged in count two of the indictment with kidnapping. To prove the crime of kidnapping, the state must prove the following three elements beyond a reasonable doubt.
(37:18)
One, Dwain C. Hall forcibly, secretly or by threat confined, abducted or imprisoned Sonia Exelby against her will. Two, Dwain C. Hall had no lawful authority to do so. Three, Dwain C. Hall acted with intent to inflict bodily harm upon or to terrorize Sonia Exelby. Secretly means the defendant intended to isolate or insulate Sonia Exelby from meaningful contact or meaningful communication with the public. If the evidence does not convince you that the defendant committed the main crime of which he is accused in count two of the indictment, there may be sufficient evidence that he committed lesser included crimes. In other words, if you decide the main accusation has not been proved beyond a reasonable doubt, you'll need to decide if the state proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty of a lesser included crime. The lesser included crime of kidnapping is false imprisonment. To prove the crime of false imprisonment, the state must prove the following two elements beyond a reasonable doubt.
(38:06)
One, Dwain C. Hall forcibly, secretly or by threat confined, abducted or imprisoned Sonia Exelby against her will. Two, Dwain C. Hall had no lawful authority to do so. Secretly means the defendant intended to isolate or insulate Sonia Exelby from meaningful contact or meaningful communication with the public. The defendant has entered a plea of not guilty. This means you must presume or believe the defendant is innocent. The presumption stays with the defendant as to each material allegation in the indictment through each stage of the trial, unless it has been overcome by the evidence to the exclusion of and beyond a reasonable doubt. To overcome the defendant's presumption of innocence, the state has the burden of proving the crime with which the defendant is charged, was committed, and the defendant is the person who committed the crime. The defendant is not required to present evidence or prove anything.
(38:52)
The law does not require proof beyond all doubt on the part of the jury before it returns a verdict of guilty. A mere possible speculative, imaginary or forced doubt is not a reasonable doubt. A reasonable doubt is not a guess or mere conjecture. Rather, it is a doubt based upon reasoning and common sense after careful and impartial consideration of all of the evidence in the case. A reasonable doubt as to the guilt of the defendant may arise from the evidence, conflict in the evidence or lack of evidence. If after a careful and impartial consideration of all the evidence, you have a reasonable doubt as to the guilt of the accused, it is your duty to find the defendant not guilty. On the other hand, if after a careful and impartial consideration of all the evidence, you are convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty, it is your duty to find the defendant guilty. It is to the evidence introduced in this trial and it alone that you are to look for that proof.
(39:41)
The evidence that has been admitted to show other crimes, wrongs or acts allegedly committed by the defendant may be considered by you, but only as that evidence relates to proof of motive or intent. However, the defendant cannot be convicted for a crime, wrong or act that is not included in the indictment. It is up to you to decide what evidence is reliable. You should use your common sense in deciding which is the best evidence and which evidence should not be relied upon in considering your verdict. You may find some of the evidence not reliable or less reliable than other evidence. You should consider how the witnesses acted as well as what they said. Some things you should consider are one, did the witness seem to have an opportunity to see and know the things about which the witness testified? Two, did the witness seem to have an accurate memory?
(40:20)
Three, was the witness honest and straightforward in answering questions? Four, did the witness have some interest in how the case should be decided? Five, does the witness's testimony agree with the other testimony and other evidence in the case? Whether the state has met its burden of proof does not depend upon the number of witnesses it has called or upon the number of exhibits it has offered, but instead upon the nature and quality of the evidence presented. The fact that a witness is employed in law enforcement does not mean that his or her testimony deserves more or less consideration than that of any other witness. Expert witnesses are like other witnesses with one exception. The law permits an expert witness to give his or her opinion. However, an expert's opinion is reliable only when given on a subject about which you believe him or her to be an expert.
(41:03)
Like other witnesses, you may believe or disbelieve all or any part of an expert's testimony. It is entirely proper for a lawyer to talk to a witness about what testimony the witness would give if called to the courtroom. The witness should not be discredited by talking to a lawyer about his or her testimony. You may rely upon your own conclusion about the credibility of any witness. A juror may believe or disbelieve all or any part of the evidence or the testimony of any witness. The constitution requires the state to prove its accusations against the defendant. It is not necessary for the defendant to disprove anything, nor is the defendant required to prove his innocence. It is up to the state to prove the defendant's guilt by evidence. The defendant exercised a fundamental right by choosing not to be a witness in this case. You must not view this as an admission of guilt or be influenced in any way by his decision.
(41:49)
No juror should ever be concerned that the defendant did or did not take the witness stand to give testimony in the case. The statement claimed to have been made by the defendant outside of court has been introduced into evidence. Such a statement should be considered with caution and be weighed with great care to make certain it was freely and voluntarily made. If you conclude that the defendant made the statement, you must also determine from the evidence whether the defendant's statement was freely and voluntarily made. In making this determination, you should consider the circumstances including but not limited to, one, whether when the defendant made the statement he had been threatened to get him to make it and two, whether anyone had promised him anything to get him to make the statement. If you conclude the defendant made the out of court statement, but it was not freely and voluntarily made, you should disregard it.
(42:32)
During the trial, a recorded interview was admitted into evidence between Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie, Sergeant Joseph Miller and Dwain Hall. The recording contains the opinions and statements of Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie and Sergeant Joseph Miller. These opinions and statements are pertinent only to explain the reactions and responses they elicited. You are not to consider these opinions and statements by Special Agent Rebecca McKenzie or Sergeant Joseph Miller as true, but only to establish the context of Dwain Hall's reactions and responses. The attorneys will now present their final arguments. Please remember that what the attorneys say is not evidence instruction on the law. However, do listen closely to their arguments. They are intended to aid you in understanding the case. Each side will have equal time, but the state is entitled to divide this time between an opening argument and a rebuttal argument after the defense has given its closing argument. With that said, ladies and gentlemen, the attorneys have each been allotted 90 minutes. Ms. Berndt, would you like a notification when you have a certain amount remaining?
Ms. Berndt (43:28):
No, Your Honor.
Judge (43:28):
Okay.
Ms. Berndt (43:30):
May it please the court?
Judge (43:31):
Yes, ma'am.
Ms. Berndt (43:31):
Counsel. Good morning, members of the jury. This is Sonia Exelby. Now that you've heard all of the evidence, you know that everything I told you in the opening statement about Sonia is true. She was 32 years old, she was beautiful, she was kind, and she was deeply loved by everyone who knew her. And she also suffered from mental illness for most of her life. She should be alive today. She had survived many mental health crises in her life before. She had counselors. She had Stevie who would do anything for her. She had friends. She had her family who were always there to support her. She would've made it through this crisis as well, but no one could save her from the defendant, the Alpha Sadist. Think about what he must have said to her over those two years. How did he manipulate her to get her to leave her home and travel thousands of miles to come here? What did he say to her? What made her think that she would be successful with him in her attempt to commit suicide by proxy?
(45:08)
He took advantage of a severely depressed, mentally ill woman who was incapable of making any rational decisions for his own sadistic pleasure, and that's why we're here today. And this woman should be alive today. You've heard in those jury instructions that the defendant is charged with first degree murder, but there's two lesser included offenses, second degree murder and manslaughter. And those instructions tell you that you have to find the defendant guilty of the highest crime that we have proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and that's going to be first degree murder because the other two choices, second degree murder and manslaughter, don't include premeditation. And if there was any murder that was premeditated, it was this one. So I suggest to you that after you look through the first degree murder elements, which we're going to talk about, you don't go any further because it was premeditated and second degree murder and manslaughter don't apply in this case. And the judge read you this. These are the elements.
(46:20)
There are only three things that we have to prove to you to find the defendant guilty of first degree murder and only these three things. One, Sonia Exelby is dead. That's already proven beyond a reasonable doubt. We know that she's deceased. Unfortunately, we had to see the pictures. They've stipulated that it was Sonia Exelby. There's no question about that. Number one, it's easily checked off. There's no dispute about that. Two is the death was caused by the criminal act of Dwain Hall, which we'll talk about in a minute. And three, there was a premeditated killing of Sonia Exelby. Let's talk about the premeditation first. What does that mean? I know some of you watch a lot of true-crime shows and you may think that premeditation means a long time of claim. We have that here, but that's not exactly what it means. Killing with premeditation is killing after consciously deciding to do so. The decision must be present in the mind at the time of the killing.
(47:20)
The law does not fix the exact period of time that must pass between the formation of the premeditated intent to kill and the killing. The period of time must be long enough to allow reflection by the defendant. The premeditated intent to kill must be formed before the killing. And probably one of the most important things is that Sonia Exelby's consent is not a defense to the crime of first degree murder. I submit to you, I'm going to show you some things that I think prove that she didn't want to be killed when she came here and she changed her mind. But even if you don't believe that, if you believe that she came here and she 100% wanted this man to kill her, he can't do that. She cannot consent to that. He can't do it. I think we proved to you she changed her mind, but again, even if you do not believe that, this man does not have the right to kill her even if she wants to die. So that is not even a consideration. How do we know it's premeditated?
(48:23)
Well, they've been planning this since February of 2025 because in February of 2025, she paid Silver Wolf $3 and then she paid him $500. And all of those bank records are in evidence. You can look through those and you'll see that. So they were planning this since February and then something happened and it didn't go through in February. So then they planned it again for October. She bought those tickets in September 22nd of 2025 and she booked the Airbnb. I mean, it was weeks they had this planned. He bought the paracord, the utility rope at Walmart on that Friday at 5:47. And remember, even if you think that it wasn't planned when she booked the plane ticket, it certainly was planned when he went to Walmart and bought all the supplies. He bought a shovel and rope. He knew what he was going to do with that shovel because right after that he went to the airport to pick her up.
(49:26)
He bought the shovel and the rope, 5:54 and 5:47, then he went right to the airport when her flight came in at 6:22. And then what else does he buy? Tarp. He buys tarp before he kills her. And after he buys the tarp, he goes to Dunkin Donuts first and right to the burial site. How much premeditation do we need? Shovel, rope, tarp. And then to top it all off, we have this which shows the, and remember when you look at these, the UK records are, this is the month and this is the day and this is the year. And these are the records that I told you about. She paid Royal Inn in Ocala 91 pounds in February. And then down here in March, she paid Solver Wolf $500. And here's the $3 one, March, a hotel in February and then she paid him in March. And he was kind enough to give us a lot of video footage of him buying all the things that he was going to use to murder her.
(50:38)
Here we go, strutting along outside of Walmart with a shovel. Here's the rope. This is the same rope that he bought that we never found. And here he is walking through Lowe's with his tarp. Never found that either, but here's a picture of that exact tarp. So we have the receipts and we know he bought it because we have the pictures of him buying it. Clearly it was premeditated. There's no question this was a premeditated murder. We have receipts, we have videos, we have photographs, we have everything. So if number one is proven beyond a reasonable doubt and number three is proven beyond a reasonable doubt, all we have is one thing left. Did he do it? Is her death caused by the criminal act? Because if that's proven beyond a reasonable doubt, you have to find him guilty. How do we know that? Let's talk about the suicide.
(51:36)
So think about this, if this makes any sense. For years, Sonia's been trying to find someone to kill her because she couldn't do it herself for at least two years. Her prior suicide attempts were overdoses by prescription medication. Stevie told us that. She pays him $1,200 to kill her. She flies overseas. She comes to Florida and then she gets here and then all of a sudden she's like, "Oh no. Oh no, Alpha Sadist. I got this. I'm going to stab myself." Does that make any sense? All of a sudden she can't kill herself for two years. She's desperately trying to find somebody to do it. She goes through all this and gets here and then she's like, "Oh, I got it. I'm going to kill myself?" It's ridiculous. I'm sorry that we have to look at these again, but you can see they're on the left side right here and these are the closeups. We know Sonia's right hand and I asked Stevie that. She would've had to use her left hand to do that. Her right hand is never going to reach around there. Those stab wounds were four to seven inches deep. The medical examiner said it would take significant force and speed to obtain those wounds. She couldn't do that one time, let alone four. The pain of that would be excruciating. If you think about every wound that she had and Dr. Lang talked about where they went, every one of them hit a vital structure, the stomach, spleen, pancreas, kidney, diaphragm, ribs. I mean, there is no way she would be able to get that knife in one time, let alone four times.
(53:42)
And again, she's going to do this herself. So she comes here and says, "I'm going to kill myself." So she takes the knife in her non-dominant hand and starts stabbing herself back here? It makes no sense at all. And it's impossible. There's no way she could have done that to herself with the pain that she would've been in from one of those. This was no suicide. There's no evidence of that, that she did this herself. And if it was, why did he tell the police that? Wow, he should have made up a really long story for four hours. They said, "We know she's suicidal." They told him that. If that happened, he goes, "Yeah, okay. She came here and then she killed herself." I guess he knew he couldn't do that because then he would have to say, "Well, then I threw her in the grave and I buried her and took all of her stuff and got rid of it." But the police ask him, "Did you kill Sonia?" And this is what he says.
Video: Speaker 5 (54:47):
Did you kill Sonia?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (54:48):
I can't tell you that.
Ms. Berndt (54:51):
He says, "I can't tell you that." Did you kill Sonia?" Point-blank they ask him? He says, "I can't tell you that?" If it was a suicide by her own hand, certainly he would've told them that. He admits he's got violent ideations. He doesn't want to talk about them specifically, but he admits it.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (55:13):
I may occasionally have the violent ideations or whatever, but at the same time, it's better left on paper.
Video: Speaker 1 (55:24):
Yeah. No, I hear that. I mean, there's a lot of people that leave it on paper. So what type of violent ideations?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (55:27):
I don't feel comfortable discussing that with you.
Ms. Berndt (55:34):
He doesn't feel comfortable discussing his violent ideations with her. And he admits that the plan was for Sonia to come here so he could kill her. He admits that.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (55:46):
Really got into that, just that she met up with a few guys or she was supposed to meet up with a few guys and they always stood her up and/or cowarded out and fell in love with her. It is exactly what-
Video: Speaker 1 (56:03):
So they couldn't follow through with it?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (56:05):
They wouldn't follow through with it.
Video: Speaker 1 (56:06):
Okay.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (56:09):
That's basically what that came down to.
Video: Speaker 1 (56:12):
Okay. So she came to you with the hopes that you could follow through with it?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (56:16):
Apparently.
Video: Speaker 1 (56:16):
Yeah.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (56:19):
Apparently that was the original plan.
Ms. Berndt (56:22):
That was the plan. So there's no dispute that that's why she came here, and he admits that that's why she came here. And then you have this horrible video that he made of her, and he asks her, he thinks this is going to help him somehow. He asks her, "What have you been consenting to here today?" And she says, "You mean you're talking about killing me? Are you talking about killing me?" He says, "What have you been consenting to?" And she says, "You're talking about killing me? Is that what you mean?" And then he says, "You consent to what beforehand? What do you feel that you deserve?" And she says, "To be stabbed." And he says, "Huh?" And she says, "To be stabbed." And this video is in evidence, and you're going to have a laptop back there with you. You can watch it as many times as you need to and listen to it as many times as you need to. This is what she says. He asks her, "What do you consent to?" Which she can't consent to that. He knew it. "To be stabbed." That's what she says. That's what the plan was. He was going to stab her, and she says it right here.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (57:42):
What have you been consenting to here today?
Video: Sonia Exelby (57:49):
You mean the way that you're talking about killing me? Yeah. Is that what you mean?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (58:00):
Huh?
Video: Sonia Exelby (58:02):
Is that what you mean? Sorry.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (58:05):
You consent to what kind of treatment beforehand that you feel like you deserved?
Video: Sonia Exelby (58:25):
To be stabbed.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (58:26):
Huh?
Video: Sonia Exelby (58:26):
To be stabbed.
Ms. Berndt (58:35):
There's just more evidence that he killed her. Shovel. You know he bought that shovel before he picked her up from the airport, and that shovel's found in his garage. It has her blood on the handle. Is he saying she stabbed herself and then dug her own grave? How is her blood on the handle? Her blood's on the handle because he stabbed her and then he buried her. There's no other reason her blood's on that handle. And it has his fingerprint on it. And we know that that shovel was the one used to dig the grave. You know how we know? Because thank you, he left the label in the grave. The label for that shovel is in the grave. And you can look at the receipt. It matches up the SKU numbers with the one he bought. Thanks for that evidence because you left the label in the grave so we know it was the same shovel. I mean, I don't know how much more evidence we need than her blood is on the handle, his fingerprint's on the shovel that he bought to kill her.
(59:40)
There's no other way her blood got on that handle. His knife is a murder weapon. His friend Rick Snyder bought him that knife as a present prior to the murder. That knife is consistent with the size and shape of those stab wounds. Dr. Lang looked at it and said yes. But we don't even need Dr. Lang to say yes, it matches the stab wounds because Sonia's blood's on it. And where is it? Under the handle and the screws on both sides of the knife. How did he get there? When he stabbed her, it went in and the blood went up. It was on both sides under the screws of that handle when they took that handle off. How did that get there? It's his knife. It's the murder weapon. Her blood's on it. And he mailed it away and tried to get rid of it. I mean, we've got the murder weapon with her blood. We've got the shovel with her blood at his house that he bought. How much evidence does there need to be that he is the one that killed her?
(01:00:49)
Oh, I'm sorry. There's more because he was at the burial site from 9:38 to 10:50. His Life360 shows it right here. That's where he is right after he buys the tarp. What's he doing there for that long, for an hour and 20 minutes? And we've got him there. And more, we're going to cover everything up. Why are we covering everything up? He murders her and he buries her. Then he goes to Butler Plaza in Gainesville and we know he puts her backpack in that recycling bin because I mean, there's nothing more the Florida Department of Law Enforcement could have done in this case. They got every piece of evidence they possibly could and left no stone unturned. They sent an agent to the recycling bin in Tampa to go through that huge truck you saw of everything that was in there. And did they find Sonia's bag? They did. They found her bag. Stevie identified it. When you look at those pictures, he initialed it and said, "That's Sonia's bag." We don't even need Stevie to identify it because his DNA is on it and so is Sonia's.
(01:02:09)
But he got rid of that. Where is the utility rope? The paracord and the tarp? He got rid of those somewhere. Those are all gone. And we know because there's the empty wrappers were in the Airbnb. Those were the empty wrappers, the paracord and utility cord, but those things were not found there, just the empty wrappers. So he's disposed of those. And he drives by her burial site again later on that Sunday to see if there's any cops out there, anybody sniffing around. Then Tuesday wakes up, first place he goes is UPS. I'm going to mail that knife and get this knife out of here. Then he comes back to his house and does what's called a batch deletion. Every photograph of Sonia and that video he made, he deletes. He is on the coverup now. He's going to get rid of everything. I don't want any race of her on my phone anywhere. He lies to the police.
(01:03:09)
And then he does get a little concerned because on October 15th, and this is in evidence too, he asked Gemini, which on an Android phone is like Siri, "How long would it take a large family dog to decompose?" Why does he want to know that? Because he's hoping that's going to decompose and nobody's going to find her body. There's no other reason he's searching that. We don't have to prove motive. You see those three elements. Nowhere in there does it say motive. We don't have to prove motive. We only have to prove those three elements. But I think in this case it's important to talk about it because we know why. And lots of times the juries want to know why. We don't have to prove it to anybody. We know why. He targeted her because of her mental illness and exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure. And how do we know that? We know all about her mental health. We talked about that to show you why she would go to these websites. Why would somebody go to these websites and ask to have these things done and come here for that?
(01:04:09)
You obviously have to be mentally ill. We know her history, both her parents suffered from mental illness. Her father suffered from addiction as well. And Dr. Demery said that there's lots of components of mental illness that can be hereditary. She had a traumatic childhood. She was removed from her home, put in foster care, separated from her siblings. There was some indication of sexual abuse after she was taken from her biological parents. And for Stevie, she was a wonderful, amazing person when she had low self-esteem was always one of her problems. And Stevie said she was crying up for help in the letter that she wrote from the plaintiff. We know from Dr. Demery that he reviewed all the records. There was mental health records. There was hospital records going back to her teenage years. He interviewed Stevie who knew her the best. That's who he interviewed. He listened to all the interviews. He personally interviewed Stevie, talked to him.
(01:05:04)
And he talked about why somebody cuts and does self-harm, that the immediate physical pain of cutting yourself alleviates the emotional pain, just so you try to have you understand why she was doing what she was doing. Even though she stopped cutting, going onto these horrible websites where they would talk about vile sexual violence took the place of the cutting and made her forget the emotional distress that she was in when she went to these websites. He talked about all the disorders. She was bipolar. She had bulimia, anorexia, borderline personality disorder, depressive disorder. She was vulnerable. And when she was murdered, she was suffering from serious mental illness. And anyone who'd spent time with her would know that she's not capable of making rational decisions. She was a highly vulnerable mentally ill female and she was conflicted and ambivalent about wanting to die-
Ms. Berndt (01:06:00):
... female. She was conflicted and ambivalent about wanting to die. And we don't have the communications between them, but why don't we have them? Because he deleted his Motherless account and with the account when he deleted it, all the communications were deleted. And then they got on Sessions. And he knows Sessions is automatically deleting things and there was no chance we were ever going to get anything from sessions. But as I said before, I think the lack of messages is more telling because he got rid of them all. But again, think about what had to be in those messages to get her to come here. It wasn't just they talked a couple times on Motherless or Sessions, "Hey, how are you? Blah, blah, blah." He said he was communicating with her for two years and it had to be very substantial communication and very manipulative and predatory by him because there's no way she would've come here without that. And again, why did he do it? Motive? We know what he wants because he himself wrote it. This is nobody making this up. This is his own bio, Alpha Sadist. "Well, I'm a sadist. I like 18 to 25 year old generally. I enjoy mother-daughter sets as slaves. Would love to find a domestic pain slut for complete control. No scat or puke play. Only complete submission is acceptable. "Which is what he wanted from her, which is why he picked her and why he targeted her. This is his other bio. "Live in Florida, sadist. Want to find my own little sex doll for all sorts of things." That's that guy. That's who he is. That's how he describes himself and what he's looking for. So even though we don't need to prove motive, we know what the motive is and we know why. And in this clip from the interview, he talks about telling her to have sex with Stevie, he calls her husband or fiance, and he's directing her what to do with Stevie. And then Agent McKenzie starts asking him, "So she did it and you liked it. Was it for the control?" And he goes, "Yeah." He did it for the control. He wanted to see if you could control her. "I'm going to tell you what sexual acts to do with your fiance. I'm going to see if she'll do it."
Audio: Agent McKenzie (01:08:34):
So is that her thing to be submissive?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:08:38):
Yeah. Yeah. That's what I've gotten. That's what I got from her when we were talking [inaudible 01:08:42]
Audio: Agent McKenzie (01:08:42):
So is that kind of like the turn on because she was submissive and online you're telling her to be more assertive with her husband or her boyfriend and trying to get her to be more sexually aggressive with him? Or what was the appeal of giving her direction to have sex with someone?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:09:01):
The control. Just the control.
Audio: Agent McKenzie (01:09:05):
Controlling her?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:09:06):
Mm-hmm.
Audio: Agent McKenzie (01:09:08):
So that's what kind of just fed you, turned you on that you could get her to try something that maybe she wasn't comfortable with because you said it wasn't how she typically had sex and you were able to kind of push her to do those things?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:09:22):
Yeah.
Ms. Berndt (01:09:22):
Yeah, control. Complete control. He admits it. We've proven how he did it and why he did it. One, two, and three. Those are the three things. We know she's dead. There's more than enough evidence that he's the one that did it and we know it was premeditated. And because those three things have been proven beyond a reasonable doubt, you have to find him guilty of the first-degree murder.
(01:09:57)
We also have the second charge, which is kidnapping. And like the first-degree murder, there's also a lesser included offense in this, which is false imprisonment. These are the three elements for the kidnapping. And what I'll tell you is the false imprisonment is the same as one and two. There's just no three in the false imprisonment. There's no intent to inflict bodily harm or to terrorize someone. Of course, I would submit to you that that's clearly the reason he brought her here was to do that to her so the false imprisonment doesn't apply.
(01:10:28)
And I want to be clear that for the kidnapping, we are not talking about her getting on the plane and coming here. She did that on her own. That's not the kidnapping. The kidnapping started when she got here and then she clearly changed her mind and wanted to leave and he told her, "You're not leaving unless you shoot me." That's when the kidnapping starts. We're not talking about her flying here on the plane and coming here. She did that on her own. I mean, although she wasn't manipulated by him, but she did that on her own. So the kidnapping starts once she gets here and after she's endured beatings from him and he's terrorized her, that's the kidnapping.
(01:11:08)
We talked about this second thoughts. Was she conflicted? Was she sure? We know she booked a return flight and we know she didn't do that to trick her family because her family didn't even know she was leaving anywhere. So why'd she book a return flight? And this is something we haven't talked about either that's in the records, the bank records. On the day before she left on Thursday before she left to the US, she had two bank accounts we've talked about, Tesco Bank account and the Lloyds Bank account. She transferred 950 pounds from her Lloyds Bank account to her Tesco Bank account. That meant her Lloyds Bank account had a negative balance. So she moved that money out of her Lloyds account and she had a negative balance. The Lloyds account is the one that he kept trying to charge for his business that were declining.
(01:11:58)
She knew there was no money in that account because she had transferred it out the day before. And then when she gets here and he's demanding the money, she gives him that card. She knew there was no money on that card because she had just transferred it out. Was she hoping that when it didn't go through... Because remember he said she kept insisting there was money on the card. Was she hoping that it wouldn't go through and he would maybe kick her out and let her leave and say, "I'm not going to kill you because you didn't pay me?" Seems kind of obvious. There's no other reason that she would've given him that card. These are the bank records and again, they're in evidence.
(01:12:43)
The conversion time is October 9th at 10:04. She transferred $950 out of that account and it put her in the negative. And then here's all the times he's trying, trying, trying, and he's decreasing the amount. He keeps trying four times and she knew. She knew there was no money in that account. Why would she do that? Hoping that he would say, "Get out of here. You didn't give me the money. I'm not going to kill you." There's no other reason she would do that except hoping she could get out of this terrible situation. And then she switched over and she ended up giving him the other card that had the money on it. And that's when he got the $1,200. I mean, we can look at the video, we know what kind of condition she was in, but she eventually gave him the card so he got the money.
(01:13:41)
And this is the letter. I know it was hard to hear. It's in evidence, when Stevie read it was hard to read with the connection, but this is the letter that she wrote from the plane on her way here. "I've never hurt so much. I'm trying so hard not to have a panic attack. I'm scared enough to leave home soil and Don't You (Forget About Me) is playing. It's such cruel irony. That was the song I almost died to in an attempted suicide. I haven't really heard it since.
(01:14:17)
As soon as the wheels leave the ground, I wish I was home, but I can't get off the plane and it's moving and I have no Wi-Fi." What is that saying? "I wish I was home, but I can't get off the plane. I'm screaming like I'm in a Saw trap. I want to beg for help so badly, but there's such a wall it will never happen. The Virgin intro, Virgin Airlines intro saying, 'The end.' Oh God, I feel so sick. I can hear it powdering up. Why am I here? Why? The guy in front of me looks like Barry." He's her brother. "If I wasn't numb, I'd never have gotten out of the house. This would be impossible.
(01:15:03)
Although I'm hurting more than I ever have, but that's exactly why. Any worse than I'd scream bloody murder. I thought I was calming down, but then the worst fear swept over me as I feel us speeding up. I hate that I can see my reflection in the screen. All the staff have been so wonderful. I know they want to help me and I could just tell them, but I can't. The crushing realization that my singing yesterday didn't even record. I offended my phone. It was everything and I left nothing. Well, now I'm so depressed I'm not hurting as much. And there we go like a fucking rocket. It's too late. Oh, I thought we took off. I've never felt panic like this. Everyone can give to the world except me. I just take.
(01:15:53)
"It almost looks like a perfect day above the clouds. Why do I still feel like I'm not going to die? I fucked up so badly not leaving the trace at the end. I got too overwhelmed and forgot things. If I manage to get to him, it'll be so easy to find me. I'll be mutilated and disabled for the rest of my life."
(01:16:20)
This is the condition that she was in when she wrote this and when she went to him. Was she having second thoughts? Was she panicked? Did she want to get off the plane? Certainly looks that.
(01:16:43)
Did he act with intent to inflict bodily harm or terrorize her? I'm going to submit to you he did both. Let's first talk about how he feels about women. We know how he feels about women because you had to look at those horrific 17 images that were on his phone involving the torture and rape and mutilation of women. I'm just going to put one of them up. This is how he feels about women. They're not human. Hate it, rape it, execute it. That's what he thinks about women. That's what he thought about Sonia and he did whatever he wanted to her when she got her there. And she kind of left us a note by reaching out to Ari about what she was going through. He wouldn't let her leave unless he shot him. He made it clear there was no way out unless I shoot him. That can only mean that she asked to leave. She wanted to leave and he said, "There's no way. You want to leave? You got to shoot me." Is that terrorizing and playing with somebody? We know he had a gun because we found it. Did he inflict bodily harm on her and terrorize her? Clearly.
(01:18:10)
First, he made her record a disclaimer and message my family because he thought it was funny. He thought that video he took of her beaten and broken was funny. And she said, this was on Saturday, Friday night, we know once they got back to the Airbnb, they were there all night until the next morning, "Last night was so bad. Every time I pass out, I wake up crying." So whatever he did to her was bad enough. She was passing out. "I can't even take a choke and the disorientation makes me truly believe I'm with you and I keep crying your name when I realize I'm not dreaming. I'm so scared. I'm so broken and I'm in so much pain."
(01:19:05)
He put her in emotional pain as well as physical pain. Did he terrorize her and inflict bodily harm on her when he wouldn't let her leave the Airbnb? Yes. You see the bruising here? The bruising here? We know this is the rope that he had. The rope, the original rope is gone, but this is the exact same kind he had as well as the paracord. And if you look at her breasts right here, that's not from a smacking. He admitted he smacked her on the ass, front, the back, smacked her on the face a couple times, smacked her on the breast. That's not a smacking. That looks like a rope right here and then across here. And we know, I'm not going to show it to you, but they're in evidence that there are pictures he had on his phone of women's breasts being tightly bound with rope. Is that physical pain? Is this terrorizing someone?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:20:19):
Please tell me about why you're here.
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:20:20):
Because I'm an awful person and I am to die.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:20:32):
Yeah, but why are you such an awful person?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:20:39):
I've crushed everyone who ever loves me. I've cheated on my partner many times. God, the amount of lie to everyone about this is overwhelming. Led on so many men because I didn't know how to just... Well, it was more just that I didn't have the guts to say no because I knew they probably wouldn't like me or... I don't know. People just always seemed overly nice. Yeah, I was always an oddball.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:21:42):
And how did you want to die? What was your chosen way to die? Kind of describe that. What have you been consenting to here today?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:21:58):
You mean the way that you're talking about killing me? Yeah. Is that what you mean?
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:22:11):
Huh?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:22:12):
Is that what you mean? Sorry.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:22:15):
You consent to what kind of treatment beforehand that you feel like you deserved?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:22:20):
To be stabbed.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:22:20):
Huh?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:22:34):
To be stabbed.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:22:36):
Yeah, that's what you want. But the last day or two, what has your treatment been? What did you ask for leading up to that?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:22:53):
I can't remember. We've talked about so many different ways.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:23:01):
What's this on your face?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:23:12):
You've beaten me.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:23:14):
Is that what you wanted? Is that what you asked for?
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:23:26):
I guess literally speaking.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:23:31):
Now you're being coerced. Are you being forced into this? And this is how you wanted to die, right? You wanted to be beaten and made to suffer because you're such a piece of shit? Say it.
Video: Sonia Exelby (01:24:07):
I needed to be beaten and suffer because I'm such a piece of shit.
Video: Dwain C. Hall (01:24:12):
Good, good. You're not being forced to say that, right? So are you getting what you wanted? Are you pleased? Are you happy?
Ms. Berndt (01:24:40):
This is what Sonia absolutely looked like on the left before she came here and met with Alpha Sadist, the defendant. This is what she looked like after. We ask that you find the defendant guilty of first-degree murder and kidnapping. Thank you.
Judge (01:25:00):
Mr. Barrett?
Mr. Barrett (01:25:19):
Dealing with the death of a loved one is never an easy thing to do. It doesn't matter whether or not the death is natural causes or from suicide. We will always think that they're gone too soon. You start to ask yourself, "Could we have done more? Did we miss something? Is it our fault?" All of this is natural. Just as it is natural for you to have emotional reaction, Ms. Exelby is dead. There's no question about that. The question for you to decide is how she died and who caused her death. If the question of how she died, it's been answered for you. The medical examiner told you how she died. So the remaining question I suggest to you is who took her life? All the other elements of the crime are clearly established. So the question is who caused her death? There is no question that she suffered from several mental health issues. We've heard from her boyfriend, her sisters, that sometimes she had good days, essentially, and sometimes she had bad days. Her boyfriend at some point went with her for counseling to a therapist. She was on medication. The idea was to help her to deal with the mental illness. But one of the things you must keep in the back of your mind, and again, personal experiences, is that not every death or every suicide is caused by mental illness. Sometimes people just decide that they don't want to live anymore.
(01:28:06)
We talk about every day an individual's right to life and we oftentimes avoid the question of the individual's right to die. Mental illness is not always obvious. Dr. Demery told you that. Through your life experience, you have probably passed someone on the street just laying there, sitting there. It's not always someone just getting up and acting weird. It's not always someone who has mental illness. It can be controlled at times. In the case of Ms. Exelby, we know that she had several different type of mental illness, and part of it sometimes she is at one stage where she's fine, she can do her day-to-day activities, and next time it is different. The people who have been around her, her life, her sisters, or boyfriend of 10 plus years, you've heard them tell you that when she's in that bad stage, she doesn't want to speak to anyone. She avoids them. They understand that. They've been around her life.
(01:29:37)
You heard that the day she left the United Kingdom to come to the United States, she was happy. You heard that from her boyfriend. She did her hair. She was in a good mood. You heard that the month before, sometime in September, she was able to book a flight, book an Airbnb. She was able to plan it essentially just around the time she was supposed to meet up with her sisters. Her boyfriend knew she was going to be gone because, again, she wants to meet with her sisters. Her plan to come to the US was done around the same time. I suggest to you that was an action of somebody who was, at that time, mentally in a good place. She knew what she was doing. She made those plans, and she made it in such a way that they would not know she's gone.
(01:30:51)
Now, the fact that she bought a round-trip ticket, those of you who have traveled know if you're going to another country, you got to go through immigration. If you have a one-way ticket, even coming from the UK where you don't need a visa to come to the US, if you buy a one-way ticket, they're not letting you in. You have to buy a round-trip ticket. This way, they know you're planning on leaving. You have to provide information about where you're going to stay. Again, conscious though, planning. She made those plans herself to come to the US, and yet she came here with the intention of dying. She felt she was worthless, not useful, a burden on other people. And she felt that by dying, that was essentially her gift to her family. She would no longer be a burden. Again, I suggest you that took some thought.
(01:32:11)
We know that she likes porn that maybe the average person doesn't like. We know that Mr. Hall does that also. This is not a question about what kind of porn he likes. It is not illegal, unless it involve child porn or some type of porn that is illegal. It is not. You're not here to judge somebody's lifestyle. State introduced 17 photographs and if you choose to look at this photograph, some of these photographs are not anything that happened to this woman. There's no evidence that she had some kind of an object inserted in her. No evidence that she was tied up. No evidence of objects coming through her chest. Those are all emotional elements that the state has introduced in this trial.
(01:33:20)
You can disagree with him about what he likes, but that is not the issue in this case. This case should not be decided because you're just angry at anyone or because you don't like his lifestyle. You don't like the type of things he likes. Here in the video, you hear him talking about what he likes. Yes, you can consider that perverted if you choose to, but the fact that that's what he likes does not make it illegal. Did you see any photographs or pictures of him actually engaging in any of those activities not been introduced in this trial?
(01:34:09)
There's been several witnesses and a lot of stuff introduced in this trial. The state presents a case the way they want to present the case. That is their responsibility. It is their duty to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, so yes. But most of these things introduced doesn't really tell you anything about who killed her. There's no question that at some point he was around her. The video showing purchasing stuff, the state talk about the rope. There's no evidence that at some point he had beat her with a rope, tied her up. Medical examiner or no one else have told you that they see any indication that any of those things happened. He talk about spanking. In fact, he had quite a discussion with the detective about safe words and about if the individual flinches, you stop right there. Again, it's in evidence. You can listen to it. There's no evidence of her being bound, tired. You talk about choking, but the medical examiner told you that there's no evidence of strangulation. Again, you may not like the way he engaged in sexual activity, but that in and of itself does not make it illegal.
(01:35:57)
Ms. Exelby came here because she wanted to die. She attempted this several time before, wasn't successful. She wanted to be away from her family. And you heard in this interview, she didn't want them to find her. She lied to them about where she was going. She booked two different places to stay. The state talked to her about some inn, Royal Inn, I believe was the name that she said. But we know she did and that Mr. Hall booked the Airbnb. So she did everything to make sure that the family didn't know where she at.
(01:36:42)
Now on the plane, did she start thinking about what was going to happen and think about it? Yeah, you heard the interviews. When she got off the plane, she still had the opportunity, if that's what she wanted to change her mind, to not get out of the airport. We know she's made contact with at least one friend. She could have told him where she's staying. She may not be able to give him a direction as to where this Airbnb is, but she's the one who booked it, which means she had to have gone somewhere to get that information. "This is it. This is where it's located." She could have provided that if that's what she want. She was upset. What was she upset about? Because she didn't think it would take that long for her to die. That's one of the things Dr. Demery spoke to you about. Was he playing her along for his sexual gratification? Could be. Did he kill her? That's the question for you. She wanted to die. She wanted to die quickly. He wasn't doing that.
(01:38:05)
There was no question that the knife was involved in her death. Now yes, the state asked both the boyfriend and I believe one of the sisters if she right-handed or left-handed. Does the fact that you have a dominant hand, excuse me, means that you're not capable of using your other hand? Is it possible for her to stop herself with her left hand? I think one of you asked the question of the doctor about speed and the-
Mr. Barrett (01:39:00):
... of the doctor about speed, and the doctor told you she couldn't tell you that. They didn't measure speed. To do that, they would actually have to get a human being and do testing, which is not allowed. But words are important. The words we use are important. And that was one of the questions I asked of the doctor when she talked about whether or not she could have killed herself. And I believe, and let me try to get as close to the words she used as possible, because again, words are important. When asked whether or not the injuries could have been self-inflicted, the response, and again, this was a state question, from the doctor was, "Typically not consistent with."
(01:40:14)
And I got up there and asked her about that. You used the word typical, what does that mean? Again, common sense. Yeah, normally that may not be consistent, but typically it doesn't mean it could not happen. And in fact, I would suggest when the doctor responded, she gave an opening, in essence, to the state by saying it is not outside the realm of possibility.
(01:40:46)
My phone is supposed to be off, so that shouldn't be mine. Apologize. I definitely... Okay.
Judge (01:40:52):
This is a direction if anyone has a cell phone or electronic device it needs to be off, not in silent or vibrating mode. Members of the news media obviously are exempt if they're operating equipment necessary for the television of this trial. Continue.
Mr. Barrett (01:41:06):
Her response to me was not outside the realm of possibility because it could happen. Depends on the strength of the hand. I suggest to you what she actually meant was not just the hand but the whole arm, because obviously it's not just a hand movement. It requires strength. Someone who has made up her mind that she wants to die. We often, in our own life experience, talk about that extra strength when you're in a situation out of fear or anger. Could she have done it herself? We know she was angry because he wouldn't do it. Could she have done it herself? We know that the Airbnb was searched. They got a warrant, they searched, they recovered all kind of things. We know that Mr. Hall's home was searched. No evidence of blood on shoes



